Fans of Netflix’s limited series Sirens are left with plenty of questions after the emotionally charged finale. With characters played by Milly Alcock, Meghann Fahy, and Julianne Moore capturing hearts, viewers are eager to know: Will there be a second season? Creator Molly Smith Metzler offers insight into what the future might hold for these compelling characters and the possibility of continuing the story.
The ending that leaves us wanting more
Sirens wrapped up its limited run with a finale full of intrigue, unresolved questions, and a delicate balance of intimacy and mystery. The scenes of Peter (Kevin Bacon) and Simone (Milly Alcock) breathing heavily in separate settings — Peter in his room, Simone on a beach — left audiences wondering about their connection. Metzler explains the creative intention behind this powerful visual.
“We wanted it to feel like a shared experience,” Metzler says. “Simone’s doing what Simone’s doing, and Peter’s having a panic attack. The scene is meant to feel like the power of true seduction, true intimacy.” The breathing sequences represent a subconscious bond between the two characters, linking their emotional states without explicit explanation. Metzler also admits she found the scene a bit sexy and “loved their performances,” hinting at the complicated pull between them.
The final beach conversation between Peter and Simone, though unseen by the audience, was fully written by Metzler during development. She deliberately withheld the actual dialogue to keep the moment more evocative and open to interpretation. “The not knowing is sexier and keeps us on our toes,” she says. This choice adds to the show’s mysterious tone, allowing viewers to imagine what might have been said between the two.
What’s next for Michaela and Devon?
While Simone and Peter’s connection dominated much discussion, other characters’ futures also sparked curiosity. Michaela (Julianne Moore) ends the series at a crossroads, leaving behind a prosperous law career and facing an uncertain future. Metzler praises Moore’s nuanced performance, portraying Michaela’s mixture of devastation and newfound freedom.
“She’s clearly devastated to leave her old life but there’s a calmness, a feeling of ‘I can be me again,’” Metzler says. Michaela’s journey is one of reinvention, and Metzler imagines multiple possibilities for her — returning to law, moving to a quiet place, or even pursuing a newfound passion for rare birds. “I think she’s going to land on her feet,” Metzler assures fans.
Devon’s (Meghann Fahy) storyline resonates with many viewers dealing with real-life challenges. She returns to Buffalo to care for her ailing father, sacrificing personal happiness and romantic prospects in the process. Metzler reflects on the emotional weight of this role: “There are so many people in this position today — without money, resources, or plans.” Devon’s character embodies resilience, responsibility, and the struggle to find balance.
“Devon says, ‘The best thing I’ve ever done is take care of Simone,’” Metzler notes. Yet, the weekend depicted in Sirens marks a turning point. Metzler believes Devon is on a path toward sobriety, self-respect, and healthier relationships, hinting that love with Jordan (her new interest) may be in her future. It’s a bittersweet but hopeful arc for the character.
The possibility of season two: Dreams, doubts, and hope
Despite the strong fan response and open questions, Sirens was conceived as a limited series, leaving the door for future seasons wide open but uncertain. Metzler expresses genuine love for these characters, whose stories she has carried since writing the original play 15 years ago. “I could write them until the day I die,” she says.
When asked about the possibility of continuing the show, Metzler answers thoughtfully: “I’d never say never. Could I do them justice in another season? I’d have to think about it.” She stresses that any return would need to be for the right reason — a worthy story and not just to satisfy demand.
The enthusiasm of fans asking for more is encouraging, and Metzler jokes about calling Netflix’s Ted Sarandos to pitch a second season. “It would be an incredible honor to work with this cast again,” she admits, emphasizing the deep connections among the team. However, she remains cautious about ensuring a sequel would uphold the quality and complexity of the original.
For those wondering about a baby for Simone and Peter, Metzler teases, “I think they’d have a baby because he said he might want more kids, and she’ll want to please him.” Milly Alcock herself has joked about Simone getting pregnant “as soon as possible,” hinting at potential future developments if the show returns.
Behind the scenes: Tone, cast, and creative vision
One of Sirens’ greatest achievements is its unique tonal blend — a seamless mix of dark comedy, drama, mystery, and emotional depth. Metzler credits this success to a committed creative team, including director Nicole Kassell and director of photography Greg Middleton, who all shared a unified vision.
“It’s a very specific tone, but you don’t get to control that yourself,” Metzler explains. “You have to build an incredible team.” Their collaborative effort resulted in a show that balances humor and sadness, intimacy and suspense, all while maintaining a mysterious atmosphere.
The cast chemistry also shines both on and off screen. Metzler describes a joyful, respectful working environment, praising Julianne Moore’s generosity and the genuine affection among the actors. “There was so much joy, and that always comes from the top,” she says. A fun insider detail: the haunting female vocal heard in the show is actually Meghann Fahy’s own singing — an Easter egg for attentive fans and a testament to the cast’s multifaceted talents.
What lies beyond the ferry?
The show closes with Michaela and Devon on a ferry, a symbolic moment that Metzler had envisioned from the start. It represents transition, uncertainty, and the cyclical nature of the story. Meanwhile, Simone’s final shot by the water, wearing a pale blue gown, bookends the series beautifully.
“That moment feels like a tale as old as time,” Metzler reflects, referencing the show’s mythological inspirations. Simone’s ambiguous expression leaves viewers wondering if she is victorious, resigned, or both — perfectly capturing the show’s complex emotional landscape. With unanswered questions about relationships, personal journeys, and the mysterious Kell compound staff, Sirens leaves ample space for imagination. Will Simone become the new Mrs. Kell? Will Peter and Simone’s connection deepen? Will Michaela and Devon find peace and purpose?
For now, fans must wait. But with creator Molly Smith Metzler’s passion and the audience’s love for these characters, the possibility of Sirens season two remains alive — a siren’s call that many hope Netflix will answer.
If you loved Sirens, keep an eye out for updates from Netflix and Molly Smith Metzler. Until then, rewatch the series and savor the nuances, because sometimes the best stories are those that leave you wanting more.
